Aug 042009
 

The House of Representatives voted on the American Clean Energy & Security Act of 2009. I haven’t read the bill, and I doubt our congressmen have either, but it the idea that you can just pass a bill and magically our county’s energy problems are solved is very naive. Furthermore the efficiency targets of the bill are unrealistic even if they are a good idea. What really makes me mad is- efficiency is its own reward. If these ASHRAE 90.1 reductions were so easy to obtain everyone would be doing it for the cost savings. The fact that few are speaks volumes. The few that are, are using government sponsored utility rebates or mandated government regulations. It is never a good idea for the government to interfere with the market, especially when the outcome is so questionable. I am happy to see I’m not the only one who things so. In the August edition of Engineered Systems Magazine (page 8), they polled readers on the bill and the outcome wasn’t good. These are professionals who love energy efficient solutions, so you better believe they have more insight than congressmen who voted on this bill, or the green lobbyists who probably wrote.

 

What is your current impression of the ACES energy efficiency targets?

ES Reader Poll

Controlling Interest Clean Air Focus
Realistic and a good idea 14.9% 18.4%
Unrealistic but still a good idea 49.6% 21.0%
Unrealistic and a bad idea 32.6% 55.3%
Not sure 02.8% 05.3%

What is your opinion of the awards structure in the ACES Bill?

 

ES Reader Poll

Controlling Interest Clean Air Focus
A significant and effective owner incentive 19.9% 05.3%
Moderate effect, but less than anticipated 44.0% 39.5%
Little or no effect on retrofit pace/ quality 31.9% 44.7%
No opinion 04.2% 10.5%

source: Engineering Systems, August 2008, page 8

  One Response to “ACES Low”

  1. A similar poll was taken at Pollution Engineering Magazine regarding Global Warming issues. The results show their readers are not happy with what the Federal Government has proposed and has doubts about Global Warming in general. Poll Results

    “Overall, there was a significant drop across the board from respondents in the justification and necessity of CO2, Carbon, or GHG control.”

    I’m waiting for the US Government to ban gravity.